Mild Hot Sauce

  • Classic Hot Sauce Variety Pack Not Too Hot Sauce
    Classic Hot Sauce Variety Pack Not Too Hot Sauce

    Classic Hot Sauce Variety Pack

    $35.99
    Regular price
  • Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce - Not Too Hot Sauce
    Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce Not Too Hot Sauce

    Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce

    $9.99
    Regular price
  • Cha-Cha-Sriracha 7 oz. Sriracha Hot Sauce - Not Too Hot Sauce
    Cha-Cha-Sriracha 7 oz. Sriracha Hot Sauce Not Too Hot Sauce

    Cha-Cha-Sriracha 7 oz. Sriracha Hot Sauce

    $9.99
    Regular price
  • Jalapeño Business 7 oz. Jalapeño Lime Hot Sauce - Not Too Hot Sauce
    Jalapeño Business 7 oz. Jalapeño Lime Hot Sauce Not Too Hot Sauce

    Jalapeño Business 7 oz. Jalapeño Lime Hot Sauce

    $9.99
    Regular price
  • Gingerella 7 oz. Red Jalapeño Ginger Hot Sauce - Not Too Hot Sauce
    Gingerella 7 oz. Red Jalapeño Ginger Hot Sauce Not Too Hot Sauce

    Gingerella 7 oz. Red Jalapeño Ginger Hot Sauce

    $9.99
    Regular price

See What Our Customers Have to Say

  • ★★★★★

    “It is packed with flavor. It’s mild with a tiny amount of heat its robust flavor holds its own with any hot sriracha sauce I’ve ever tasted. Even my heat loving family loved it.”

    Cynthia R.
  • ★★★★★

    “Fantastic flavor, not too hot, it really goes great on anything & everything! First of MANY bottles”

    Sean F.
  • ★★★★★

    “Great all-around sauce. Tons of flavor. Have tried it with meat, eggs, rice and pairs really well with each of those. Would and will buy again!”

    Jared C.
  • ★★★★★

    “SO delicious and approachable with a nice slight kick and wonderful flavor. Order on repeat. Will be gifting to my girlfriends, for sure.”

    Ashley M.
  • ★★★★★

    “Between the 4 flavors, these can be used on virtually anything to add some extra flavor and a slight kick. These will be a staple in my fridge!”

    Steven G.

Why Mild Hot Sauce?

Looking for a hot sauce that brings all the flavor with just the right amount of heat? Then our mild hot sauces are the perfect options for you!

Not Too Hot Sauce was created with the purpose of making deliciously toned down hot sauces that anyone can enjoy. With four distinct flavors, each of our mild hot sauces are designed to have an approachable heat level and a flavor that will keep you coming back for more.

We've learned that people often conflate mild hot sauce with non-spicy condiments, such as ketchup, but we're here to tell you that our sauce still packs a (mild) punch. Each of our sauces are made with chili peppers, so they all have some level of spiciness to them. The Jalapeño Business and Gingerella are our mildest sauces, while the Creamy Buff-alo and Cha-Cha Sriracha carry a bit more heat.

Whether you want a subtler heat, a new go-to condiment, or a hot sauce that everyone can enjoy, we have you covered.

Mild Hot Sauce FAQs

Mild hot sauce has a lower heat level than more traditional hot sauces. This toned down spiciness can be accomplished by removing the seeds and the pith of peppers, using less spicy peppers, or using fewer peppers in the final product.

Here at Not Too Hot Sauce, we use peppers that are lower on the Scoville scale, so our sauces come out milder. Additionally, we temper the sauces with non-spicy ingredients, such as bell peppers or tomatoes, to reduce the overall heat level of each sauce.

Our two mildest sauces are Jalapeño Business and Gingerella. Each of these have a very approachable heat level and can be used on a variety of foods, such as tacos, rice dishes, and eggs.

Our mildest hot sauces leave a slight tingle on the tongue with a short-lasting heat, while some of our sauces that lean closer to medium have a spiciness that lingers for a bit longer.